Why Domino Dominates

Mat Newman  October 5 2010 05:02:39
Why does Domino Dominate ... even 13 years after this poster was released, the content still holds true:

Image:Why Domino Dominates

History tells us that: No, Netscape was never a dominant player in the groupware market.

Interestingly, somewhere along the way, the original message for Domino got lost.  How many analysts still see Domino as a Development environment?  How many within IBM still sing that tune?

"When it comes to industrial-strength collaboration, Lotus Notes and Domino... is peerless.  It's robust object store, powerful directory, unparalleled security, and rich development environment make it the perfect choice for companies looking for an all-in-one, mission-critical groupware package.  You will not go wrong with Notes and Domino." (LAN Times, "Growing Groupware," July 1997)

Image:Why Domino Dominates

History also shows us that Microsoft were trying to feed us lines in 1997 as well, again the difference is that analysts didn't believe the FUD back then...

"Microsoft has positioned Exchange as a serious competitor to the mature Lotus Notes.  It would have us believe that Exchange is capable of sustaining the messaging requirements of the biggest companies, as well as being a feature-rich application development environment.  In other words, it's a bit of a whopper." (InformationWeek United Kingdom, "Time to get it right," November 6, 1997)

Image:Why Domino Dominates

We all know that Exchange public folders and forms libraries were never a match for Domino, even Microsoft have been trying to wean their users off them for the last couple of releases, and changed their tune to include Sharepoint as the development environment equivalent of Domino.

Why does Domino Dominate?

I believe the earlier quote sums it up best: "all-in-one".  There is nothing like building an application in a single data container, and then hosting that application on a platform that exposes web-services, messaging, directory integration, presence and multi-client access.  You don't have to integrate with anything, you don't need to write code to ensure that the pieces are communicating and playing together, it just works.

Compare that "all-in-one" approach to an SQL data store, a web front end surfaced in Sharepoint hosted on IIS, written in .Net (isn't that a joy to code to read/write data back to SQL!  NOT), hopefully smart-tagged properly so that Office (Excel, Word or Access) can interpret the content, and then distributed through Exchange, which looks great when viewed in 1280x1024 through Internet Explorer on Windows.  Hmmmm.

Yes, Microsoft are still telling everyone 'Whoppers".

And Domino is still all about the Apps.  And the fact that an Application can be/is a template so that when someone asks "we need a new application similar to blah-blah that does...."

Sure boss.  File-Application-New...  Just give me 20 minutes and I'll have it ready for you!

1Giulio  10/05/2010 16:33:43  
Why Domino Dominates

Matt... Well said, but your quotes are from 1997 even when Notes was nowhere near as functional as it is now. That message no longer reverberates. Not because it isn't true, but the vendor is chasing different game now.

IBM have not maintained this message, nor follow it very well themselves.

It seems alot of the ASW chatter in the Domino space relates to mobile apps, which frankly limits it to email and contacts.... <yawn>, it's been done to death/the barrier to entry on the platform device is low to the point that 2 guys in a garage can compete with IBM on this and make it look sexier, so not really a great competitive advantage as a platform.

Xpages is good to hear about but this is geek stuff to a small (and shrinking) community, it doesn't reach the general business consumer IT infrastructure channel which is where it needs to be heard loud and true.

What would help this message Matt, is to mention it in conjunction with the end results from all those sharepoint/Exchange migrations going on around the world, and whether or not they deliver the Notes-free utopia espoused by so many MS pundits.

Mat Newman

THE Notes (formerly IBM/Lotus Notes) Guy. Productivity Guru. Evangelist. IBM Champion for IBM Collaboration Solutions, 2011/2012/2013. Former IBMer. HCLite. Views are my own.

#GetProductive #GetHCLNotes

Mat Newman

Home  | 

Get Serious. Get Domino.