matnewman.com

Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

Mat Newman  April 14 2010 22:00:00
A little while ago I wrote about content management, and why I trust my content to the ultimate content manager: Lotus Notes.

About the time I wrote that article I had been working with a customer to move into a Lotus Notes project management system from - you guessed it - Microsoft Excel.

Mick Moignard's recent comments also got me thinking.  If Notes is so great, why don't more users love it?

The last couple of weeks has provided me with the answer.

I have been doing a lot of Excel training lately, especially concentrating on advanced functionality within the Excel software.  As part of my training classes, I always encourage participants to bring along their own work - or examples of other peoples -  that they are having trouble understanding or working with.  There are some really strong reasons for conducting training in this manner:
1.        You can cover the same concepts as you are supposed to be delivering from the "standard" course outline,
2.        The user gets a better understanding of a concept and functionality because they can see it in use in a relevant context, and
3.        So what if you don't follow the book.  If the customer "gets" what they are paying for, and you have achieved the same outcome as following some meaningless example from a book, where's the foul?


I know a lot of Instructors don't feel comfortable stepping outside a student guide or lab exercises in order to conduct a course.  My own opinion on this: if you're not confident enough with a piece of software to "wing it" with live examples in a training class, what on earth are you doing teaching a class where someone might ask you a question slightly off the course outline?

Back to the topic.  What I have seen in my Excel sessions in the last couple of months is some REALLY clever stuff done by END USERS.  I'm talking about exports of data from ERP systems and databases that have had some very complex Excel formulas and functions thrown at that data.

What I have constantly seen are users compiling lists of data in Microsoft Excel, and then trying to manage that data as though it were in a DATA BASE!

And here's the point:

If plain old END USERS are able to do some outstanding stuff in Excel, why do(es) IT limit them by not giving them development tools that allow them to move beyond simple list management.  I believe that tools like Microsoft Sharepoint are winning users "hearts and minds" simply because it (SharePoint) allows them to do the same stuff they have always done in Excel, but now makes it more flexible and extends it to a wider audience, since the user is no longer limited to a local file stored on a share, but now extends that list-based data to a wider audience, WITHOUT emailing an excel file all over the place.

Forget about audit trail's. change history, security and data integrity.  We're talking list management here, and users are primarily interested in simple list management tools. Not to mention easy data-entry (Fill-Handle anyone?)

Until we in the Lotus world can convince end-users of the benefits of audit-trails, change-history, security and data integrity; we are never going to win the end users "heart's and minds".  Until IT enables end-users with tools like Domino Designer, an end user is never going to understand/accept the RAD (Rapid Application Development) environment that Lotus Software provides, let alone give up the only data management tool that their IT's SOE (Standard Operating Environment) has provided them with since Windows NT and Office 95!

Trust me ... your end users are creating everything from simple list management to full-blown project management applications within Microsoft Excel.  And I really do mean full-blown cost-analysis, justification, task tracking Project Management Tools - in Microsoft Excel.  Give them half a chance and someone from a shop that has already implemented Microsoft Sharepoint will join your organisation, and tell that user how they can easily extend that application to the rest of the organisation.  At that point.  Good-bye Lotus software.

If you don't realise how prevalent Excel (or even Word) are as user-based development tools in your own IT environment - consider the last time you filled in an expense claim, travel request or leave application.  If you filled in a Word document or Excel spreadsheet (and then had to work out WHERE to email that file too), you have lost control of your IT environment.  If you don't already have Notes applications that cater for these simple workflow applications that Notes excels (no pun intended) at, you MUST take a look at the types of systems your users are implementing right under your nose!

How do you fix this in your organisation?

Simple.

Either:
A.        Hire a competent developer who is pro-active in searching for user "applications" based in Excel who can convert those "applications" into Lotus Notes, or
B.        Train some of your "Power Users" building Excel apps in how to build forms and views in Domino designer.

I am yet to meet someone who has been trained competently in the use of Domino Designer, who has an ounce of initiative, and a drive to resolve "problems" not being addressed within a formal IT development cycle who doesn't like Notes as a development platform.

The upshot - Domino Designer as of 8.5 is now FREE.  How much?  Yes FREE!

Now if you can get it (Domino Designer) into your SOE, and a few power users interested in developing NOTES rather than EXCEL applications, Notes has a future in your company.

If you insist on giving users Word, Excel and Notes as base applications in your SOE - without giving them a development tool - they will continue to develop applications in the only software available to them ... Microsoft Excel.
Comments

1Erik Brooks  04/15/2010 3:31:09  
Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

2 words: Auto Filter.

Reporting/graphs aside, one of the most convenient features of Excel vs Notes is how it lets you slice up data sets. Pivot tables functionality is ~80% duplicated by views (though have fun copying/pasting) but Auto-Filter is the Killer Feature for large data sets.

2Wayne Sobers  04/15/2010 4:40:52  
Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

Microsoft knew this years ago, and Oracle is now doing the same.

That's why Excel stomped all over 1-2-3.

IBM still really don't know what to do with Notes and continue to throw new features into it without improving on the existing feature set. The sad thing is, IBM have a better track record for upgrades than MS, yet each time a new version of notes comes out, existing problems are not resolved. Instead we have a new paradigm or feature to learn.

3Jerry Carter  04/15/2010 23:33:34  
Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

The way I see it, project classification is the issue. We see all the stuff people (including me, a Domino developer) do in Excel and wonder why not Notes? Scale.

Notes Domino has a feature set suitable to distributed list management where security is required.

Excel has a feature set suitable to small adhoc needs that the user can morph to fit whim without additional tools.

Similarly, Websphere / J2EE has a feature set suitable to large, global exposure high traffic applications where component abstraction is critical to project maintainability and scalability.

It's a mistake to try to fit all project sizes and scopes in one tool set. I've used Excel for project estimating and actual time vs estimate time tracking for several years. Could I do it in Notes? Yes, but it would take longer and I'd be adding in a host of features that the task really doesn't demand... and some things would just be silly to try to emulate when Excel does them so well.

I've preached for a long time (back when I actively blogged) that we ought not be just "Notes Developers" but "technologists" and "evangelists". Understand all technologies you can get your arms around and how to best apply them, evangelize people with good project management and application design patterns and methods. But don't fall into the old view: "have hammer, will nail, everything is a nail".

4Mat Newman

05/08/2010 13:11:13  Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

@Eric - Autofilter is definitely feature of Excel that makes it a great list management tool. I would LOVE to see a similar option included in Notes.

@Wayne - Spot on regarding the feature set, I can't believe that Notes 8* (standard/eclipse) is missing at least 11 features that are still available in the Notes 8.* Basic client. Things like Ctrl+Tab drive me nuts switching between versions.

@Jerry - Agree with the "have hammer" comment. The thing about Excel lists though, is that they get out of hand really quickly. A great example are things like registers; Mail registers, Document registers, Asset registers, etc. These are the types of spreadsheets that I see constantly that are thrown into Excel simply because either:

a) the users dont realise a database would be better at managing the data, or

b) the user does not have access to a database aplication within their SOE.

I need to write an entry on my most recent customer who used to have an unbelievable number of spreadsheets to record stuff like this, that is now in Notes.

Mat Newman IBM Champion

5excel training course¬†  08/16/2012 16:28:53  
Microsoft Excel, the greatest development environment known to ... End Users.

I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff on your post! :)

Mat Newman

THE Lotus Notes Guy. Productivity Guru. Social Evangelist. IBM Champion for IBM Collaboration Solutions, 2011/2012/2013. IBMer. Views are my own.

#GetProductive #GetLotusNotes

Mat Newman

New to IBM Lotus Notes? START HERE



I'm attending. IBM Software.
      Lotusphere 2012. Business. Made Social. January 15 - 19. Orlando,
      FL. Drive Adoption for IBM Connections



Home  | 

Get Serious. Get Domino.